BMWP-PL - how to calculate the macroinvertebrate biotic index
A study of benthic macroinvertebrates ends with a list of organisms - and the BMWP-PL index turns it into a single, comparable number describing water quality. It is one of the most popular biotic indicators; it is worth understanding how it arises.
The idea: points for each family
BMWP-PL is the version adapted to Polish fauna: it covers 88 families (the Kownacki and Soszka methodology, 2004), each scored from 1 to 10 according to sensitivity to oxygen deficits and to the toxic products of organic matter decomposition. An extract from the scale, with examples from each level:
| Points | Character of the families | Examples |
|---|---|---|
| 10 | the most sensitive; clean, well-oxygenated water | Ameletidae, Glossosomatidae, Odontoceridae, Leptoceridae, Blephariceridae |
| 9 | very sensitive | Taeniopterygidae, Cordulegastridae, Goeridae, Lepidostomatidae |
| 8 | sensitive | Astacidae, Perlidae, Philopotamidae, Heptageniidae |
| 7 | moderately sensitive | Ephemeridae, Caenidae, Limnephilidae, Elmidae, Unionidae |
| 6 | intermediate | Gammaridae, Baetidae, Simuliidae, Coenagrionidae |
| 5 | moderately tolerant | Hydropsychidae, Dytiscidae, Notonectidae, Hydrobiidae |
| 4 | tolerant | Ceratopogonidae, Planorbidae, Sphaeriidae, Valvatidae |
| 3 | clearly tolerant | Chironomidae, Asellidae, Erpobdellidae, Glossiphoniidae |
| 2 | very tolerant | Oligochaeta, Culicidae |
| 1 | extremely tolerant; heavily loaded water | Syrphidae, Psychodidae |
The scored families with their points are in the BMWP-PL / ASPT calculator - you tick the families you found, and the calculator sums the points and computes ASPT.
⚠️ The list there holds 118 entries, not 88. In the GIOŚ handbook the list exists in two versions: the river one (App. IV, 88 entries - the one that feeds ASPT_PL inside MMI_PL) and a broader one, for lakes and dam reservoirs (App. II/III). The latter adds Osmylidae, Spongillidae, Lestidae, Nereidae, Bryozoa and Araneae among others and splits Heptageniidae into two genus-level entries: Epeorus and Rhithrogena at 8 points, the remaining genera at 6 points. The scores in both layers come from the same source. Entries off the river list are marked in the calculator; you can hide them in the list, but ticked ones still count. If you are working up a river sample, you stay at family level: the river list (App. IV) scores the whole Heptageniidae family at 8 and never goes lower.
How to calculate it
- Identify the organisms to family level.
- For each family present, read off its score from the BMWP-PL table.
- Sum the scores of all families → this is the BMWP.
- Calculate the ASPT (Average Score Per Taxon) = BMWP ÷ the number of scored families.
Example. You found four families in the sample: Leptoceridae (10), Baetidae (6), Gammaridae (6) and Chironomidae (3).
BMWP = 10 + 6 + 6 + 3 = 25 ASPT = 25 ÷ 4 = 6.25
What counts is the presence of families (not the abundance of individuals): ten freshwater shrimps and one count the same.
How to read the result
- high BMWP and ASPT → clean, well-oxygenated water, rich in sensitive families,
- low values → loading (most often with organic matter and an oxygen deficit).
ASPT is more stable than BMWP alone, and that is arithmetic rather than taste: BMWP grows with every family found, so it rewards greater effort - longer sampling gives a higher sum at the same site. ASPT divides by the number of families, so it measures the quality of the assemblage, not the size of the sample.
What BMWP-PL does not do: it is not the official classification
Five quality classes were historically defined for BMWP-PL itself, but the ecological status of rivers in the Polish state monitoring is not assessed with this index today. The index in force is MMI_PL (the Polish Multi-Metric Index), in which ASPT is one of six components - the one with the greatest weight. You do not put raw values into the formula but normalised values (WJE, the ecological quality ratio):
MMI_PL = 0.334 × WJE(ASPT_PL) + 0.266 × WJE(log₁₀(Sel_EPTD + 1)) + 0.167 × WJE(S) + 0.083 × WJE(EPT) + 0.083 × WJE(H′) + 0.067 × WJE(1 − GOLD)
Each metric is first normalised to an ecological quality ratio: WJE = (metric − DPZ) / (GPZ − DPZ), where DPZ and GPZ (the lower and upper anchor points) are the 5th and 95th percentile of that metric’s distribution in the biocenotic river type (six types; values in table 3 of the GIOŚ handbook, pp. 148-149). A result below 0 is recorded as 0, above 1 as 1. S is the number of families, EPT the number of mayfly, stonefly and caddisfly families, H′ the Shannon-Wiener index computed from family abundances (natural logarithm), and GOLD the share of snails, oligochaetes and dipterans. The class boundaries depend on the biocenotic type of the river - different for a mountain stream and a lowland river (table 4, pp. 150-151).
In practice: BMWP-PL and ASPT serve well for your own monitoring and comparisons over time at the same site. Do not present the result as a “WFD ecological status class” - it is a different measure, not a different name for the same one.
The most common pitfalls
- imprecise identification (to family) - it changes the result,
- a different sample size/method - compare only what was collected in the same way,
- treating a single result as a verdict - what counts is the trend.
Sources
- BMWP-PL family scores (river list: 88 entries, 1-10 points) - we cite the score table from the GIOŚ edition: A. Kolada (red.) (2020), Podręcznik do monitoringu elementów biologicznych i klasyfikacji stanu ekologicznego wód powierzchniowych. Aktualizacja metod, Biblioteka Monitoringu Środowiska, GIOŚ, Warszawa, ISBN 978-83-950881-2-4 - PDF, App. IV (rivers), p. 160 and App. II/III (lakes and dam reservoirs), pp. 173-174 and 293-294.
- Source methodology: A. Kownacki, H. Soszka (2004), Wytyczne do oceny stanu rzek na podstawie makrobezkręgowców oraz do pobierania prób makrobezkręgowców w jeziorach, Zakład Ochrony Przyrody PAN, Warsaw.
- Scientific basis of the method: T. Fleituch, H. Soszka, D. Kudelska, A. Kownacki (2002), Macroinvertebrates as indicators of water quality in rivers: a scientific basis for Polish standard method, Archiv für Hydrobiologie Supplement 141: 225-239.
- List for the calculation: our BMWP-PL / ASPT calculator.
- MMI_PL - formula, WJE normalisation, anchor points and class boundaries by biocenotic river type: GIOŚ (2020), Handbook (as above), chapter Makrozoobentos w rzekach, §3.7 and §4, pp. 148-151; additionally methodological chapter (PDF).
- Methodology for lakes (the LMI index, separate from the river one): GIOŚ - method development (PDF).
🧮 Tool: BMWP-PL / ASPT calculator - mark the families found, and we will calculate the biotic index and ASPT for you. (Polish BMWP-PL variant.)
In practice
The raw data for the index is a list of families from a site and a date. In LimnoLog you record them as custom indicators (families / BMWP value / ASPT) and track the result over time alongside the water parameters. On what the index itself is against the background of other elements, we write in elements of status assessment.
Calculate it yourself
- BMWP-PL / ASPT calculator Biotic index from the list of benthic macroinvertebrate families (Polish BMWP-PL variant).
- Biodiversity indices calculator From a list of taxa and abundances, calculate Shannon-Wiener, Simpson and Pielou evenness.
See it in the LimnoLog app
Explore LimnoLog features